Scotland the Brave
Electronic cigarettes debated in Scottish committee by MPs and public health representatives.
-
by Dave Cross
Share on:
Despite some overtly paranoid and hysterical comments the balance of the contributions were very favourable towards vaping.
John Britton, director of the UK Centre for Tobacco Control Studies, embodied a common sense approach when informing Holyrood’s health committee that nicotine offers no more danger than caffeine.
Chaired by Richard Lyle MSP, the proceedings began with him asking for clarification on the contents of e-liquid – making reference to Jeremy Mean’s prior claim that “we don’t know what’s in them”.
Katherine Devlin, representing the trade body ECITA, listed out the ingredients we are all familiar with. She highlighted the pharmaceutical quality of the ingredients and the lengths gone to in order to ensure safety, noting that there are still steps to be taken. She said: “We are working on producing an emissions standard in conjunction with the British Standards Institute. It is something we should have done before today.”
Of note are three further comments she made which will impact on the industry as a whole. “We absolutely support an age restriction. Retailers say that without a mandated restriction it is very hard to achieve through self-regulation,” she informed the committee before adding, “We think nicotine free products being left outside of legislation is a mistake.”
With reference to the many small producers of liquids and potential legislation, Katherine Devlin said: “We need to push the standards on them. There should be no product out there containing nicotine without child resistance caps.”
Both Devlin and Britton cautioned against excessive legislation. “We have to be careful we don’t do more harm than good,” said Devlin.
“It is very important I think when legislating and controlling the inevitable abuses of the market that will come with electronic cigarettes, and the inherent risks within the products which we still know relatively little about – it is important to manage those risks, but not in a way that throws the baby out with the bath water, because there is a huge potential public health prize in these products,” Britton added.
Doctor Richard Simpson MSP called for a European-wide research program but Devlin cautioned that our experience to date is that the EU has been far from constructive when looking at data and any research would need to be clearly thought out in advance.
Highlighting the wealth of information already at our disposal, John Britton pointed out “we know a great deal about the long-term effects of nicotine from studies of oral tobacco in Scandinavia. Over decades of use we know a lot about the risk potential or the pattern of risk in lifetime users as opposed to non-lifetime users. And while I can’t say there is no risk, the risk is very, very low.” He also cited the ASH UK annual surveys and the work carried out by Professor Robert West.
When looking at the potential to ban vaping from public spaces, no one spoke out in support of legislation apart from Claire McDermott, a tobacco control policy officer. Concern was raised that vapers should not be legislated against as though they were still smokers and positive stories were relayed regarding the success of allowing vaping in hospitals, mental health institutions and Guernsey Prison.
John Britton pointed out that the smoking ban was introduced to protect people who work in those places and that although the evidence on e-cig use is that it does release some nicotine and toxic chemicals the levels are extremely low. Paraphrasing Robert West, he said quitting smoking is like being in a nightclub when the fire breaks out – the exit isn’t important as long as it leads out.
Dave Cross
Journalist at POTVDave is a freelance writer; with articles on music, motorbikes, football, pop-science, vaping and tobacco harm reduction in Sounds, Melody Maker, UBG, AWoL, Bike, When Saturday Comes, Vape News Magazine, and syndicated across the Johnston Press group. He was published in an anthology of “Greatest Football Writing”, but still believes this was a mistake. Dave contributes sketches to comedy shows and used to co-host a radio sketch show. He’s worked with numerous start-ups to develop content for their websites.
Join the discussion
Scotland Announces Single-Use Vape Action
A ban on the sale and supply of single-use vapes in Scotland is due to come into effect on 1 April 2025, under proposed legislation published today
-
by Dave Cross
Trading Standards Welcomes Clarity
The Chartered Trading Standards Institute says it welcomes the “clarity and action from government to tackle youth vaping” with the plan to ban disposable vapes and related announcements
-
by Dave Cross
UKVIA Writes To Sunak
The UKVIA has sent a letter to Prime Minister Rishi Sunak to 'express profound dismay and disappointment' that the government has decided to proceed with a ban on disposable vapes
-
by Dave Cross
FOI Shows Disposables Ban Folly
389 Freedom of Information requests made by leading online retailer Vape Club and one by the BBC demonstrate the extent to which a ban on disposable vapes is a complete act of folly
-
by Dave Cross
