The Formaldehyde Question
Is there formaldehyde in vapour? A study claims this to be the case but experts disagree.
-
by Dave Cross
Share on:
Formaldehyde is a toxic gas at room temperature, combined in many substances around the home and part of the aldehyde group of chemicals. It is considered dangerous to health and is linked to a number of cancers.
It is used in the manufacture of Delrin, a plastic frequently found in atomiser and mod insulators. Other uses include paints, explosives, textile production, vehicle parts, carpets and kitchen products. Oh, and food.
“The popular ‘tank system’ e-cigarettes allow users to really turn up the heat and deliver high amounts of vapour, or e-cigarette smoke,” said David H. Peyton, PSU chemistry professor. "Our research shows that when heated at higher temperatures, e-cigarette juices can vaporize and form large amounts of ‘hidden formaldehyde,’ five to 15 times higher than the amount of formaldehyde in traditional cigarettes.”
Payton has previously launched a negative written assault on vaping, and his colleague David Peyton is prone to unscientific kitty litter & think of the children scare tactics too.
The research used a variable voltage mod, and applied 3.3V and 5.0V to a top coil CE4 atomiser for 4 seconds per puff. No formaldehyde was discovered at 3.3V. At 5.0V, researchers claim to find formaldehyde levels up to 15 times higher than that found in traditional cigarette smoke.
Predictably, a huge amount of scorn has been poured on this ‘study’ by vapers, scientists and public health experts.
Clive Bates commented: “This study is so poorly designed and inherently misleading that it should not have been conducted, should not have been written up, should not have been published in the NEJM or anywhere, should not have been pitched to the media, and its finding should be completely ignored as worthless.”
Doctor Farsalinos has looked into the study and concluded that the team did not find formaldehyde but formaldehyde hemiacetals. He states: “there is absolutely no evidence that hemiacetals are toxic or carcinogenic. In fact, it is possible that the formation of hemiacetals might protect against damage induced by formaldehyde.”
All commentators are highlighting the distinct probability that what the team were measuring was a dry hit phenomenon, studied by Farsalinos, something not part of normal use of vaping equipment.
Even new vapers realise that different juices, wicks and coils require different settings in order to reach a flavour sweet spot and avoid dry hits. The clearomiser used is archaic in design and not built for 12W vaping as replicated in this experiment.
Professor Peter Hajek, Director of the Tobacco Dependence Research Unit at Barts, said: “The study went searching for formaldehyde, one of carcinogens that are also present in cigarette smoke. It found it when e-liquid was heated to maximum and drawn via long puffs by a machine. In e-cigarette use by humans, overheating the liquid generates acrid tasting ‘dry puff’, which is unpleasant and avoided rather than slowly inhaled. When a chicken is burned, the resulting black crisp will contain carcinogens but that does not mean that chicken is carcinogenic. Without overheating the e-liquid, no formaldehyde was detected.”
“Vaping may not be as safe as breathing clear mountain air, but it is much safer than smoking. It would be a shame if this study persuaded smokers who cannot or do not want to stop smoking and contemplate vaping that they might as well stick to their deadly cigarettes,” he continued.
Photo Credit:
Top Photo credit: nagillum via photopin cc
IMAGE: 'L'Assiette au Beurre' by Jossot
http://www.ssplprints.com/image/127691/formaldehyde-drinker-1907
Dave Cross
Journalist at POTVDave is a freelance writer; with articles on music, motorbikes, football, pop-science, vaping and tobacco harm reduction in Sounds, Melody Maker, UBG, AWoL, Bike, When Saturday Comes, Vape News Magazine, and syndicated across the Johnston Press group. He was published in an anthology of “Greatest Football Writing”, but still believes this was a mistake. Dave contributes sketches to comedy shows and used to co-host a radio sketch show. He’s worked with numerous start-ups to develop content for their websites.
Join the discussion
Vaping’s Not My Thing
The Food and Drug Administration is running another ridiculous and despicable anti-vaping campaign
-
by Dave Cross
Bloomberg’s Hitjob
Masquerading as a piece of journalism, Bloomberg news paints poor Portland State’s David Peyton as a victim because people dared peer-review his shoddy work
-
by Dave Cross
The American Liars Association
The American Lung Association has released a document purporting to help parents know the dangers of, and talk to their kids about, vaping. It is a outrageous collection of lies.
-
by Dave Cross
Farsalinos Flags Formaldehyde Team's Failings
Farsalinos’ criticism of a 2016 formaldehyde study rumbles on, with the doctor making an exceptionally strong rebuttal.
-
by Dave Cross
